Every week someone asks us 'should I go tile or Colorbond?' The honest answer is 'it depends' — but the variables are actually pretty clear. Here's how we frame the decision.
Upfront cost (Sydney, 2026)
| Roof type | Supply & install (per m²) | Typical home total |
|---|---|---|
| Concrete tile (new) | $95 – $135 | $22,000 – $32,000 |
| Terracotta tile (new) | $140 – $195 | $32,000 – $45,000 |
| Colorbond steel | $110 – $165 | $26,000 – $40,000 |
Lifespan and maintenance
- Concrete tile: 40–50 years, repoint every 15–20
- Terracotta tile: 60+ years, repoint every 20–25
- Colorbond: 35–50 years, near-zero maintenance
Pros and cons head to head
- Colorbond: faster install (5–8 days vs 8–14 for tile)
- Colorbond: lighter — less structural load
- Colorbond: better for solar panel mounting
- Tile: better thermal mass — cooler in summer
- Tile: dead quiet in rain
- Tile: matches Federation/character homes
- Colorbond: loud in heavy rain without acoustic insulation
- Colorbond: shows hail dents
- Tile: heavier — check structure on old homes
- Tile: needs periodic repointing
Which one we'd recommend, by situation
Federation, Californian Bungalow or character home
Stay with tile — usually terracotta. Council and resale value strongly favour matching the original profile.
1960s–80s brick home with concrete tile
Either works. If you're going solar or want low maintenance, Colorbond. If you want quiet and thermal mass, replace like-for-like.
Modern build, low pitch, solar-ready
Colorbond every time.
"We've put tile on Colorbond homes and Colorbond on tile homes — neither is 'better'. Pick the one that matches how you live in the house."
— Jeff, 2 Old Roofers
FAQ
Can I switch from tile to Colorbond?+
Yes — and it's structurally a non-issue (Colorbond is lighter). You may need to upgrade insulation for acoustic comfort.
Does Colorbond reduce my insurance?+
Sometimes — particularly in bushfire zones. Always confirm with your insurer.
Need a real roofer on the job?
45+ years on Sydney roofs. Call Jeff direct or request a written quote.
